The short answer: New York Fed research finds the direct effect of a tariff on store prices is about half done after three months, but the full effect, as U.S. suppliers pass along their own higher input costs, takes about a year. If you sell to retailers, more cost is still coming. Build your 2027 price increase now from your own landed cost, take out what you can first, and file it on each retailer’s calendar.
Most brands we talk to feel like they already took the tariff hit. They paid the higher landed cost, absorbed some, passed some along, and moved on. New research from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York says that may be only part of the bill.
The part that comes later is quieter. It arrives through the U.S. suppliers you buy from, months after the tariff itself. If you sell to retailers, that is the part your 2027 price plan needs to cover.
Why this matters right now
On Oct. 6, New York Fed economists Mary Amiti and Sebastian Heise, with Columbia’s David Weinstein, published How Fast Do Tariffs Pass Through into Consumer Prices? on the bank’s Liberty Street Economics blog. They studied 67 non-oil consumer goods categories. Four findings matter for a brand owner:
- Import prices move almost at once. The authors find import prices “rise almost one for one with tariffs in the first month,” with nearly 90% of 2025 tariffs passed into U.S. import prices.
- The store price moves less, because the store is half the price. A 10% rise in import and producer prices from tariffs raises consumer retail prices by 5.6%, because distribution margins are about half of what consumers pay for goods.
- The direct effect is fast. The rest is slow. On imported goods, about half of the price effect is in place after three months and all of it by six. But the indirect effect, through U.S.-made goods whose makers buy imported inputs, “more than doubles between six and twelve months.” In the authors’ words, “The full effect on consumer prices is reached only after about a year.”
- More is still in the pipe. The authors say about half of the rise in the price level they expect after August 2026 comes from tariffs already in place, mainly the August 2026 tariffs on Canadian goods, which are still passing through. The rest reflects the tariff increase on Canadian cars, trucks and auto parts announced for January 2027.
Big brands are already saying it out loud. Kraft Heinz CEO Steve Cahillane warned that “additional price increases are likely in 2027,” and Reynolds Consumer Products reported companywide pricing up 9% in its third quarter with retail volume down 7%, the Daily Caller reported on Nov. 6, citing the Wall Street Journal and Reynolds’ earnings release. If the largest suppliers in the aisle are filing for 2027, your buyer will see a stack of cost increase requests. Yours needs to be the one that is easy to say yes to.
What the research means for a small brand
Think of your costs in two waves.
The first wave is the tariff on what you import. Finished goods, a fragrance oil, a glass jar, a capsule machine part. You saw this on an invoice. Most brands have already priced it, or chosen to eat it.
The second wave is everyone else’s tariff. Your U.S. co-packer buys imported equipment parts. Your label printer buys imported film. Your corrugated supplier, your contract lab, your 3PL. Each of them raises prices on their own schedule, often at the new year, and often without the word “tariff” on the letter. The New York Fed’s point is that this wave builds for about a year. If you priced only the first wave, your margin is still leaking.
Our founder has spent 34 years making pricing calls inside operating businesses, where margin decides inventory, payroll, promotion, and growth. The pattern that hurts most is not one big increase. It is five small ones nobody added up until the year-end P&L.
Why a small cost increase becomes a bigger shelf increase
Retailers protect their margin as a percent, not in dollars. That means a cost increase grows on its way to the shelf.
An illustration, not a real brand: you sell an item to a retailer at $6.00, and it retails at $10.00, a 40% retail margin. Your cost goes up $0.30 and you pass the full $0.30 along, so the retailer now pays $6.30. To keep its 40% margin, the retailer needs a shelf price of $10.50. A 30 cent cost increase became a 50 cent shelf increase, and the shopper sees $10.50, not $10.30.
That is the same math the New York Fed describes from the other side: the store adds its share on top. Before you file anything, know what shelf price your request creates and where that lands next to your competitors and the store brand. We walked through that shelf math in Shelf Price Math: How to Price So Every Margin Gets Paid and the store brand gap in Your Real Competitor Is the Store Brand Next to You.
The 2027 price increase plan you can run this month
Cheapest and most important steps first. Most of it is a spreadsheet, a few calls and one email.
- Rebuild landed cost by item (one afternoon, free). For every SKU, list each cost line: goods, duty, freight, packaging, co-packer fee, warehousing. Mark which lines have already moved this year and by how much. If you cannot build this sheet, you cannot defend a price increase, and that is the first fix.
- Ask your top suppliers what is coming (a few calls, free). Call the five suppliers that make up most of your cost. Ask one question: what increases do you expect in the first half of 2027, and can you put it in writing? This is how you see the second wave before it lands on an invoice.
- Find the cost you can take out before you touch price (one to two weeks, low cost). Case pack, pallet configuration, freight consolidation, a packaging spec change, a second quote on your highest cost input. Every dollar you remove here is a dollar you do not have to ask a buyer for.
- Do the shelf math and pick the number (one day, free). Gross up your request through the retailer’s margin, as in the example above. Check where the new shelf price sits against your competitors, the store brand and any price point that matters in your aisle, such as crossing from $9.99 to $10.49. Then decide how much to pass, how much to absorb, and whether a pack size change is cleaner than a price change.
- Ask for the calendar (one email, free). Retailers typically accept cost increases only at set times, with written notice and their own forms, and the rules differ by account. Ask your buyer or broker for the window, the notice period and the form now, so you file early instead of after the margin is already gone.
- Build a one-page cost case (one day, free). Before and after cost by line, supplier letters attached, what you absorbed, what you are asking for, and the effective date. Show the buyer you took cost out first. A short, documented ask reads as a partner. A vague one reads as a margin grab.
- Plan for the volume hit (ongoing). Reynolds raised price 9% and saw volume fall 7%. Decide now how you will hold velocity at the new price: a few well-timed promotions, a value size, a stronger reason to buy. Do not fund the increase with deeper discounts; we explained why in Promo Without the Hangover.
What not to do
- Do not file twice in six months. One documented increase that covers both waves beats two small ones. A buyer who sees you twice starts asking what else you have not told them.
- Do not blame it all on tariffs. Buyers hear that word all day. Show the cost lines. If the honest answer is freight, packaging and labor, say so.
- Do not hide the increase in trade spend. Cutting promotion funding without telling the buyer is still a price increase, and it costs you the relationship. More on that in Trade Spend Is Not Marketing.
- Do not wait for a perfect forecast. Nobody, including the New York Fed, can tell you exactly where tariffs land next year. File on what you can document, and say when you will revisit it.
Next step
A price increase is a commercial decision, not a finance memo, and the brands that get theirs accepted are the ones that walk in with the math done. Our pillar post, How to Price a Consumer Product So Retailers Say Yes and You Still Make Money, covers how buyers judge a price from the shelf back. At Vantage Business Consulting, we help consumer brands rebuild landed cost, size the increase and build the cost case a buyer will accept. If 2027 includes a price change, a relaunch or a new retailer, start with the free Launch Scorecard below.